My friend Nic is so Halloween-obsessed that she has two entire rooms in her basement dedicated to storing her Halloween decor. While most people have guest rooms for human guests, hers host six (yes, six) of those 12-foot-tall giant Skellys. They’re also stuffed with more than 50 human-sized skeletons, a handful of dog and cat skeletons, flashing lights, noise machines and even a Christmas-sleigh tableau recreated with—you guessed it—skeleton reindeer.
So when she starts planning Oct. 31’s festivities in June, I just nod and hand her some candy corn. As for me, I’m on the opposite side of the spectrum: I’m a Halloween grinch. I really don’t decorate unless you count the orange flickering light bulbs I installed near my garage seven years ago and was too lazy to swap back out for real ones. But it goes beyond laziness. To be honest, I just don’t like Halloween. Little kids in costumes? Perfect, let’s do that every day. It’s everything else I could do without. Mostly, I hate the gory, terrifying yard displays because I am a giant scaredy-cat. There is a Ring camera video that still circulates among my neighbors of me getting so freaked out by one of those hands that pops out that I run away, screaming.
And yet Nic and I are the closest of friends! I think we balance each other’s holiday vibes. That said, there is one big point we disagree on: When is it OK to put out the Halloween decorations? Is it really rude to decorate your house early for Halloween? And how early is too early? The answer probably lies somewhere between her “right after the 4th of July” and my “the 4th of Never.” So for the purposes of this column, I’m defining “early” as anything before Oct. 1.
Now, put on your witch hat and let’s discuss.
Get Reader’s Digest’s Read Up newsletter for more etiquette, holidays, humor, travel, tech and fun facts all week long.
The case for decorating early
Your house, your rules. This is honestly the best argument for decorating for any holiday whenever and however you like. You paid good money for that lawn, so you should be able to decorate it however you see fit (within the realm of public decency). And it seems like a lot of people are doing it. According to a 2024 YouGov poll, 52% of people reported seeing Halloween decorations out before October—and 13% before Labor Day. Yes, there are a solid number of folks setting up Skellys for back-to-school. (Some people even keep up their Skellys year-round!)
And it does make sense: If you love Halloween, the earlier you set up your decor, the more time you have to enjoy the fun. It also sparks a sense of neighborhood camaraderie by giving people some entertainment as they take their dog on its nightly poop walk. It may even inspire some of them to get a little more festive. In a world where HOAs dictate every paint color and bush placement, this is your chance to get a little bit wild.
Decorating early also helps you work around weather if you live in a place with a, shall we say, dramatic climate. When we lived in Minnesota, people hung their Christmas lights in September—not because they were incredibly jolly but because no one wants to be on a roof in December in a foot of snow and -10 degrees. Halloween decor also went up before the first storm, and yes, that meant sometimes you had both orange jack-o’-lanterns and red-and-green roof lights at the same time. Better than frostbite!
So is a giant skeleton torso crawling out of the lawn a bit extra for a Tuesday in September? Probably. But there’s a lot to be said about the specific type of joy and anticipation that nostalgia brings, and nothing triggers that feeling like decor. Who doesn’t have a wonderful fall memory of heading out with your friends, dressed as superheroes, running through the spookily lit neighborhood and gorging yourselves with candy? See? You’re smiling already.
The case against decorating early
“Your house, your rules” is true, but your house is (probably) located in a community of people, and those people get to have a say in their environment—including when that environment gets populated with the undead. And folks do have some feelings about this: A separate 2024 YouGov poll found that 39% of people said Oct. 1 through Oct. 15 was the earliest acceptable time to put up Halloween decor, and 24% said anytime after Labor Day was fair game. Only 4% said earlier than that was fine.
That line in the previous section about Halloween decor being “within the realm of public decency” is doing a lot of heavy lifting, and for me, this is where the debate really heats up. Funny skeletons and silly gravestones are one thing; bloody heads hanging from trees are another entirely. When my kids were little, a simple walk to the park became a waking nightmare. Now that my kids are old enough to appreciate a good scare, I’ve come to realize that I just don’t. Why do we turn torture into entertainment in a world that already tortures real people? I’m not asking to ban the decorations I don’t like, but it would be nice if we could limit the amount of time I have to spend seeing them.
Then there’s the issue of competitive escalation. My neighborhood goes all-out, and I do mean all-out—I have a neighbor who sets up a haunted house every year that rivals professional scare factories. People drive from all over the city to walk through it. And while it is fun, other neighbors may feel compelled to up their Halloween game too. Nic told me that she actually lost sleep when a neighbor managed to get a sold-out skeleton Cinderella pumpkin carriage on eBay. This is how we end up in a skeleton arms race.
All of this hype can lead to a very real Halloween fatigue, well before the big day. What’s left to surprise and delight trick-or-treaters on the real All Hallows’ Eve when it’s already been out for two months?
The etiquette of putting up your Halloween decorations early
If you simply adore Halloween and can’t wait to break out the mummy-trapped-in-your-window film, there is a way to do it without being the bad neighbor. Before you do anything, consider the following:
The rules
Some cities and HOAs have specific guidelines for exactly this. Find out the rules for where you live, and abide by them or risk paying a fine.
The type of neighborhood you live in
Are you in a rural area with tons of space around you? Go hog wild! Are you in a townhouse with a postage-stamp-sized yard? Keep it small. Also know your neighborhood culture. Some places are known for their devotion to over-the-top seasonal displays and may even attract visitors. If you live there, then feel free to join in with abandon. (And if you don’t like it, accept that that is just the type of neighborhood you moved into.)
How much you’re putting up
Halloween spirit aside, living 15 feet away from someone with 10 inflatables, five skeletons with laser eyes, and three cats that jump and scream is just a lot of noise and light—especially if you leave them on all night long. Be considerate of your neighbors, and take an unbiased look at your decor placement.
How gory or over-the-top it is
Displays that involve a lot of blood, gore and/or jump scares may not be appropriate for your area. If you love that stuff, consider putting it up inside your house or saving it for the big day or, if you must, the week of Halloween. Another option is to tone it down a little.
How many young children live nearby
I’m an adult and can choose (mostly) what I see and how to handle it. Young children, on the other hand, don’t get to choose and are often genuinely terrified of scary Halloween decorations. If you live in a neighborhood with a lot of very young kids, consider keeping the decor light and fun.
What you’ll do if someone is bothered by it
Even if you do your best to make a totally appropriate seasonal display, someone can still find a reason to be upset and you can’t plan around those folks. But you should have a plan for people with legitimate issues—like lights flashing in their windows or toddlers with new night terrors. Part of living in a community is knowing how to politely compromise with those who live in it with you.
The verdict
It is not rude to decorate your house for Halloween after Sept. 30. For people looking for a firm date of the acceptable time to put up Halloween decorations, we’re giving it to you: Oct. 1 or later. You may be a little rude if you put up your decorations earlier than that, although it certainly isn’t the most egregious etiquette crime, especially if your decor vibe is lighthearted fun. But you will definitely be the rude neighbor if you put up displays that most people would find offensive or disturbing, or if your decor is so loud and obnoxious that it impedes your neighbors from living their daily lives.
But beyond the actual neighbor etiquette, Halloween can be one of those great moments that really brings people together with their community, so use your Halloween decorations as a way to get to know your neighbors, have fun together and keep everyone safe and happy. And if that involves a Cinderella skeleton pumpkin carriage, even better. Just don’t ask me to walk past it after dark.
Why trust us
Reader’s Digest has published hundreds of etiquette stories that help readers navigate communication in a changing world. We regularly cover topics such as the best messages to send for any occasion, polite habits that aren’t as polite as they seem, email and texting etiquette, business etiquette, tipping etiquette, travel etiquette and more. We’re committed to producing high-quality content by writers with expertise and experience in their field in consultation with relevant, qualified experts. We rely on reputable primary sources, including government and professional organizations and academic institutions as well as our writers’ personal experiences where appropriate. We verify all facts and data, back them with credible sourcing and revisit them over time to ensure they remain accurate and up to date. Read more about our team, our contributors and our editorial policies.
Sources:
- YouGov: “When do you typically start to see Halloween decorations in the area where you live?”
- YouGov: “When do you think is the earliest acceptable time to display Halloween decorations?”
The post Is It Really Rude to Decorate Your House Early for Halloween? appeared first on Reader's Digest.
from Reader's Digest https://ift.tt/BbFLA1a
Comments
Post a Comment