I made a social faux pas that still wakes me up at 3 a.m. with a full-body cringe. It happened 15 years ago, and I’m still spiraling about it. My friend Brooke (not her real name because I’m not about to make the same mistake twice) had weight-loss surgery. She’d been saving for years; it was going to help with serious health problems and, she hoped, help her find love in a world that equates thin with beautiful and beautiful with lovable (the saddest math equation ever). She told me because she needed someone to help her until her mom could arrive, and I’m nothing if not a good helper. She specifically asked me not to tell anyone. She wanted to surprise our friends with a big reveal.
I told someone.
Why? I was so excited for her that I couldn’t wait to share the good news. Her good news. Of course, that friend told another friend, and it wasn’t long before everyone knew. Brooke was crushed—and then, devastatingly, she forgave me. Graciously and quickly, which is honestly the worst possible outcome because it meant I couldn’t even wallow in my guilt. She should have made me grovel. I did not deserve that woman’s kindness.
I wish that were the only time I’ve done this. It is not. I’ve since reformed, partly because I kept watching people’s faces fall when their thunder got stolen and partly because becoming an etiquette columnist forced me to reckon with my own history of being rude. Humbling, truly.
But on the scale of texting your ex at 2 a.m. to skipping the tip screen at the bagel place, how rude is sharing someone else’s news, really? And is there ever a good reason to do it? Read on to find out.
Get Reader’s Digest’s Read Up newsletter for more etiquette, humor, cleaning, travel, tech and fun facts all week long.
The case for sharing someone else’s news
The most defensible reason is that something wonderful happened—new job, engagement, big promotion, acceptance to grad school, inheriting a yacht, reaching quadruple digits on Candy Crush—and the other person is too shy to share it or doesn’t want to sound like they’re bragging. (By the way, it’s not rude to share your accomplishments, but that’s an article for a different day.) You, as a good friend, want to toot their horn for them.
Or, on the flip side, something terrible has happened—a death, a serious illness, a layoff—and they’re too overwhelmed to ask for help. Quietly reaching out to their inner circle to organize meals or support isn’t gossiping. That’s love.
There’s also a scenario most etiquette columns skip: What if the news directly affects a third party? If your friend just started dating someone another friend has deep, unresolved feelings for, a gentle heads-up, delivered with care and zero editorializing, could spare everyone a very awkward dinner party.
So, yes, these are all defensible reasons. But sharing any of this news without consent still doesn’t necessarily mean you are in the right.
The case for keeping your mouth shut
People hate having their news stolen. Hate it. And sometimes they hate you for it. Social media is basically a graveyard of well-meaning people who couldn’t hold it together: the mother-in-law who posted the pregnancy announcement before the parents were ready, the cousin who uploaded wedding photos before the couple could share the professional ones, the grandfather who congratulated the grandkid on the new job on LinkedIn … before said grandkid had told his own boss he was quitting.
And then there’s the more serious category: outing someone’s sexuality, gender identity, health condition or mental health struggle before they’re ready to share it. That’s not just rude—it can cause real, lasting harm. In case I’m not being clear, it is 100% never OK to share that kind of information about someone else.
There’s also the problem of mutation. By the time your news passes through three people, it’s unrecognizable. What started as “Brooke had a medical procedure” becomes “Brooke almost died in surgery,” and now Brooke is fielding panicked calls and correcting a story she never wanted told in the first place. I didn’t just steal her thunder—I handed her a cleanup job.
Finally, you might simply be wrong. You think she got the job. You think they’re engaged. If you’re not right, now someone else has to do damage control on a rumor you started with the best of intentions.
The gray areas
There are also a few other factors that affect how rude this is:
- How close you are: Counterintuitively, the closer you are, the more careful you should be. Closeness means they trusted you with something private. Betraying that trust stings more, not less. And if you’re wondering whether something counts as private in the first place, ask yourself how you found out. Did they tell you directly, one-on-one? That’s private. Did you watch them announce it to a room full of people? That’s fair game.
- Why they haven’t shared it: There’s a big difference between “she’s waiting for the right moment to announce” and “she hasn’t told anyone because she’s scared or ashamed.” The second category deserves extra protection. If someone shared something with you that they’re still processing—a diagnosis, a pregnancy loss, a relationship ending—sitting on it isn’t just polite. It’s the minimum of good friendship.
- What kind of news it is: Medical issues, mental health, sexuality, gender identity, early pregnancy, financial struggles—assume these are confidential unless you’re explicitly told otherwise. The person shouldn’t have to label their own vulnerability with a “do not share” sticker. And for any other type of news: It’s not your call to decide whether their news is significant enough to protect. If they haven’t shared it, that’s your answer.
The verdict
I rarely give an unequivocal answer in this column—usually I’m neck-deep in nuance and “well, it depends.” But today I’m firm: Sharing someone else’s news is rude. Often very rude. It doesn’t matter if the news is happy, if your intentions were pure, or if you’ve been sitting on the information so long, it feels like it should be public by now.
If you think you have a genuinely good reason to share it, ask first and then respect the answer. A simple “Is this something you’re sharing or keeping close for now?” asked the moment they tell you takes three seconds and saves everyone weeks of slow-burn awkwardness.
What you should not do is pull someone aside and whisper, “You cannot tell anyone, but Barbara’s IVF worked and she’s pregnant with quintuplets!” Because that information is not staying with that person. You also should not concern-troll: “I just feel so terrible about Galligan going to rehab—I know you care about him, so I thought you should know.” That is gossip in a wellness-check costume. And texting the group chat “I’m only telling you guys about Albert’s failed vasectomy because I know he’s interested in dating all of you” is still sharing someone else’s news. (OK, I could maybe make a case for that one.)
And to everyone I’ve hurt this way: I am deeply, truly sorry. You deserved a friend who could keep her mouth shut for five minutes. I’m getting better, I promise.
Why trust us
Reader’s Digest has published hundreds of etiquette stories that help readers navigate communication in a changing world. We regularly cover topics such as the best messages to send for any occasion, polite habits that aren’t as polite as they seem, email and texting etiquette, business etiquette, tipping etiquette, travel etiquette and more. We’re committed to producing high-quality content by writers with expertise and experience in their field in consultation with relevant, qualified experts. We rely on reputable primary sources, including government and professional organizations and academic institutions as well as our writers’ personal experiences where appropriate. We verify all facts and data, back them with credible sourcing and revisit them over time to ensure they remain accurate and up to date. Read more about our team, our contributors and our editorial policies.
The post Is It Really Rude to Share Someone Else’s News Before They Do? appeared first on Reader's Digest.
from Reader's Digest https://ift.tt/DfX2keM
Comments
Post a Comment